M4 Fails Dust Test
Posted by David A. Homoney on December 21st, 2007
In a report in the Army Times, we hear how the M4 the current carbine used by our troops failed miserably compared to other carbine offerings. Those of use who don’t dress like Tacticool Tommy and have wet dreams about Guns and Ammo magazine understand the inherent flaws in the Stoner design. The whole shit where you eat thing being the most obvious beside caliber. So here the Army ran a test for stoppages in sandstorm type environments with the M4 against the FN SCAR Light, H&K XM8, and H&K 416. Needless to say the M4 had roughly 4 times the stoppages of the next worst platform the H&K 416. The report is quite telling. I have argued before with guys about the M16/M4 whom said all you have to do is maintain it. In war though you will not always have that time. Why chance it during a firefight. Read the article, it is quite good.
Newer carbines outperform M4 in dust test
By Matthew Cox - Staff writer
Posted : Wednesday Dec 19, 2007 11:54:45 ESTThe M4 carbine, the weapon soldiers depend on in combat, finished last in a recent “extreme dust test” to demonstrate the M4’s reliability compared to three newer carbines.
Weapons officials at the Army Test and Evaluation Command at Aberdeen Proving Ground, Md., exposed Colt Defense LLC’s M4, along with the Heckler & Koch XM8, FNH USA’s Special Operations Forces Combat Assault Rifle and the H&K 416 to sandstorm conditions from late September to late November, firing 6,000 rounds through each test weapon.
When the test was completed, ATEC officials found that the M4 performed “significantly worse” than the other three weapons, sources told Army Times.
Officials tested 10 each of the four carbine models, firing a total of 60,000 rounds per model. Here’s how they ranked, according to the total number of times each model stopped firing:
• XM8: 127 stoppages.
• MK16 SCAR Light: 226 stoppages.
• 416: 233 stoppages.
• M4: 882 stoppages.
the results of the test were “a wake-up call,” but Army officials continue to stand by the current carbine, said Brig. Gen. Mark Brown, commander of Program Executive Office Soldier, the command that is responsible for equipping soldiers.
“We take the results of this test with a great deal of interest and seriousness,” Brown said, expressing his determination to outfit soldiers with the best equipment possible.
The test results did not sway the Army’s faith in the M4, he said.
“Everybody in the Army has high confidence in this weapon,” Brown said.
Posted in Government, Guns, Military | 2 Comments »




